On April 2, 2025, the Washington State Supreme Court entered its order, rejecting the Plaintiff’s request for Direct Review with the State’s highest court. The one-page order, signed by Chief Justice, Steven Gonzalez, ordered the case to be transferred to Division I Court of Appeals.

The Plaintiffs had primarily sought Direct Review by the Supreme Court of the trial court’s dismissal of the Plaintiffs’ Consumer Protection Act (“CPA”) claim, which had to that point been the heart of the Plaintiffs’ case against various defendants, in a case that had languished in Whatcom County Superior Court for nearly 5 years. Despite this attempt, the Plaintiffs arguments were unpersuasive, and the Supreme Court sided with the City of Lynden and MJ Management’s arguments that these issues should be heard by the Court of Appeals instead. MJ Management had sought to have the entire case dismissed because of continued missed deadlines by Plaintiffs’ Counsel, but the Supreme Court decided to not dismiss the case in its entirety. “This was a significant decision by the court today, but for all practical matters, the Plaintiffs’ appeal has only just begun,” stated Jeffrey Possinger, who represented MJ Management at trial. “The Plaintiffs have essentially appealed every order that was entered in this case, and based on that, we expect their briefing to be massive[.]” said Possinger. These issues related to late court filings, and the Plaintiffs’ and their counsels’ failure to timely file their appeal of the Judgement for attorneys’ fees will likely be raised again in the Court of Appeals.

The parties, and most importantly, the rest of the homeowners at Homestead, will now have to wait to see how this latest chapter in this case unfolds with no end in sight.

Possinger Law Group represented MJ Management, O’Bryan, and Williams in the Hillis v. 18 Paradise litigation through the trial and has continued to represent MJ Management in the appeal brought by the Plaintiffs before the Washington State Supreme Court.